Amityville, NY Housing Market & Real Estate Update: Prices Up, Homes Moving Faster
Amityville, NY – February 27, 2026 – Prices stayed firm into early 2026 as homes moved faster, while inventory and rents stayed tight locally.
Amityville’s recent sales continue to read like a seller-leaning market, with pricing holding firm and homes moving noticeably faster than a year ago. For buyers and sellers, that combination tends to translate into competitive negotiations and fewer “wait and see” listings.
Market snapshot
- Median sale price: about $636K in Jan. 2026 (+7.8% year over year).
- Speed: homes averaged about 20 days on market (down from 57 days a year earlier).
- Demand signal: sale-to-list ran around 100.5%, pointing to offers landing at or slightly above asking in many cases.
Inventory and rentals
Even with steady buyer interest, supply remains relatively tight. Recent counts show about 53 homes for sale locally. On the rental side, the median rent is about $3,600, with roughly 15 active rentals, suggesting limited choice for renters compared with larger nearby markets.
What buyers are seeing in listings
Current active listings cover a wide spread, from entry-level lots in the low-$200Ks up to land offerings around $2.0M. Many single-family options appear clustered in the $600Ks to low-$700Ks, which lines up with the recent median sale price and helps explain why well-positioned homes can move quickly when priced near market.
Nearby for-sale examples (high-level)
- A smaller 2-bed home priced around $599K.
- Several 3–5 bed houses listed around $650K–$730K.
What’s showing up most in your search right now: more price cuts, more bidding wars, or more homes sitting longer?