Whitefish Bay, WI Housing Market Update (March 2, 2026)
Whitefish Bay, WI – March 2, 2026 – Redfin shows median sale price near $563K with longer market times year over year; inventory remains tight with 16 Zillow listings.
Whitefish Bay, WI buyers are still navigating a competitive market, even as recent data suggests homes are taking longer to move than this time last year. With a small number of monthly sales, the median can swing based on which homes close in a given month, so short-term changes may look larger than they feel on the ground.
Quick takeaways
- Median sale price: about $563K in Jan. 2026 (+8.5% year over year, Redfin).
- Homes sold: 8 in Jan. 2026 (Redfin).
- Time to sell: median 56 days in Jan. 2026 vs. 34 days last year (Redfin).
- Rentals: median rent $3,500 with 14 active rental listings; rent up 16.67% year over year .
Market snapshot
Redfin’s city-level trend page shows prices up year over year, while the typical home is spending more time on the market (56 days). That longer timeline can signal that buyers are taking a bit more time to decide, sellers may be pricing more ambitiously, or both. With only a handful of monthly sales reported (8 in Jan. 2026), it’s also possible for the median price to move noticeably based on the mix of homes sold.
What’s for sale (no address details)
Zillow’s for-sale search shows 16 active listings, underscoring how tight inventory remains. Based on the current visible range of listings, entry-level single-family options are showing up around $400K–$500K. Move-in-ready 4-bedroom homes are commonly listed around $650K–$1.1M, with a few luxury asks above $2M.
Locally, are more sellers adjusting pricing as days on market stretch, or are updated and well-priced homes still going quickly?