East Farmingdale Housing Update: Listings Steady as 495-Unit Project Advances

East Farmingdale’s housing market remains competitive this spring, with limited inventory and steady asking prices, while larger redevelopment plans continue to take shape along the Route 110 corridor.

Top takeaways

• Active listings remain limited, with single-family homes dominating available inventory.
• Typical asking prices cluster in the mid-$500Ks to mid-$700Ks.
• A 495-unit mixed-income project on state-owned land is moving forward.
• An overlay district aims to guide future mixed-use redevelopment.

Market snapshot

Recent market pages show only a small number of homes actively listed in East Farmingdale at any given time, reinforcing ongoing supply constraints. Average sale prices have been reported around the high-$600Ks, with homes often marketed between roughly the mid-$500Ks and mid-$700Ks depending on size and condition.

Single-family houses make up most of the current inventory, with occasional multifamily offerings. Broader Farmingdale-area listings show similar price bands, suggesting continued price resilience compared with many other Long Island submarkets.

Development & zoning

At the policy level, New York State has selected a developer to build a 495-unit mixed-income housing development on state-owned land on Conklin Street in East Farmingdale. The project is expected to include affordable and workforce components, adding meaningful new supply over time.

Separately, the Town of Babylon has outlined an East Farmingdale Overlay District intended to guide redevelopment along Route 110 and Conklin Street. The framework is designed to encourage reinvestment in underutilized sites and support compatible mixed-use and residential growth.

What’s for sale nearby

Current listings in and around East Farmingdale feature:

• Mid-sized colonials and capes with 3–4 bedrooms in established neighborhoods.
• Smaller starter homes under 1,000 square feet priced below larger move-in-ready properties.
• Select multifamily or investment-oriented properties, though supply is limited.

With few homes on the market and longer-term development still in planning phases, buyers and sellers alike are watching inventory levels closely heading into the late spring season.

What are you seeing locally — more showings, price cuts, or multiple-offer situations?

Sources