Evansville, WI housing market update: tight inventory, competitive sales
Evansville, WI – March 4, 2026 – Tight inventory and competitive conditions continue, with for-sale choices ranging from an “as-is” fixer to higher-priced new-build plans.
Top takeaways
- Pricing signals vary by source, placing recent median sale prices from the mid-$300Ks to the low-$400Ks.
- Inventory remains tight, and recent reporting indicates sellers are generally getting about asking price.
- Active choices range from an “as-is” acreage home in the mid-$100Ks to plan-style new construction in the low-to-mid $500Ks.
Market snapshot (ZIP 53536)
Realtor.com’s Evansville market dashboard lists a median home sale price of $419,900 and 30 homes for sale, and shows a 100% sale-to-list ratio in December 2025 (described as balanced conditions). Redfin, meanwhile, characterizes Evansville as very competitive and reports a median sale price of $345K last month. Taken together, the sources point to a market where demand can still show up quickly, even as the exact price “center” depends on how each platform measures and time-stamps activity.
What’s for sale right now
- About 1 acre, 3-bedroom home marketed “as-is,” listed around $158K.
- Updated 4-bedroom home listed around $450K.
- New-construction, plan-style options around $530K–$550K.
What are you seeing: more price cuts, faster offers, or buyers waiting for rates to ease?