Poynette Housing Update: Prices Firm, Limited Inventory Mid-March
Poynette, WI – March 17, 2026 – Home prices are trending up while inventory remains tight, with about two dozen listings active.
Home prices in Poynette are holding firm into mid-March, with limited inventory continuing to shape buyer and seller expectations.
Top takeaways
- Median sale price around $382K, up about 7% year over year.
- Roughly 20–25 homes actively listed in the village and surrounding area.
- Days on market near two months, signaling steady but not frenzied activity.
Market snapshot
Recent data show a median sale price near $382,000, with price per square foot notably higher than a year ago. Homes are averaging just under two months on market, and only a handful of sales have closed so far this year. That combination points to a small, supply-constrained market where well-priced homes continue to draw interest.
Active listings hover around the low-20s. The median value estimate across current listings is in the mid-$370Ks, broadly aligned with recent sale prices. Owner occupancy remains strong, and vacant inventory is limited.
What’s for sale now
- Single-family homes in the mid-$300Ks, including newer builds around $370K.
- Larger homes on acreage approaching $800K.
- Multi-family and investment opportunities in the $600Ks.
Options range from compact manufactured homes near $50K (with lot rent) to newer subdivision properties and rural homes on several acres. Buyers seeking land or proximity to the Wisconsin River will also find select listings.
Outlook
With inventory tight and prices edging higher, sellers remain in a favorable position. Buyers may see more negotiating room than during the 2021–2022 peak, but choice is still limited compared with larger Dane County markets. As spring listings come online, the next 4–6 weeks will signal whether supply improves.
What are you seeing locally — more showings, price cuts, or new listings hitting the market?
Sources